Abby (Appleby) is a promising art student whose long-term relationship with her perfect—but imaginary—boyfriend Sy (Orlando Seale, Sleepy Hollow) is going strong, until fellow student Quinn (Zano) enters the picture. Trapped into tutoring Quinn, Abby begins to fall for this flawed but flesh-and-blood reality. Now Abby must decide if she's ready for a real chance at love—and if she can let go of Sy.